<!–
Mystic is a town that combines seaside charm with a touch of the mysterious, making it an ideal spot for drinking tours. Whether you’re intrigued by ghost stories that run deeper than the waters or eager to sample local brews, Mystic offers experiences that match many interests.
The Spirits of Mystic: Cocktail Pub Crawl stands out for its spooky storytelling and historic pubs, while the Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour offers a more laid-back, beer-focused exploration of the town’s haunted past.
We’ve picked these two for their engaging guides, unique themes, and strong reviews, ensuring you’ll have a memorable night whether you prefer cocktails or craft beers.
If you’re planning your night out in Mystic, these tours provide a fun way to blend local history, spirited beverages, and a little ghostly intrigue. Read on to find out which of these tours fits your vibe—whether you’re after eerie tales with drinks or a lively beer crawl celebrating Mystic’s brewing scene.
Quick Overview
Mystic’s drinking tours range from spooky pub crawls filled with ghost stories and cocktails to beer-centric journeys through local breweries. Each experience highlights different aspects of Mystic’s historic and haunted reputation. For those interested in ghost stories paired with drinks, the Spirits of Mystic: Cocktail Pub Crawl is perfect.
If craft beer is more your style, the Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour offers a relaxed, beer-focused alternative. Below, we dive into each tour to help you decide which is right for you.
1. Spirits of Mystic: Cocktail Pub Crawl
At number one on our list, the Spirits of Mystic: Cocktail Pub Crawl combines ghost tales, haunting legends, and creative cocktails. For around $100 per person, this 2.5-hour tour takes you to three local pubs and taverns in downtown Mystic, where you’ll sample a different spirit or cocktail at each stop.
The guide weaves spooky stories of hauntings, massacres, and scandals into the walking tour, creating an immersive experience for anyone interested in Mystic’s darker side.
What makes this tour stand out is its blend of history and storytelling with drink sampling, plus the fact that it’s considered exceptionally well-rated—scoring a perfect 5.0/5 from three reviews.
Guests appreciate the engaging storytelling and the variety of drinks, with one reviewer noting, “Our guide was wonderful, a great storyteller and fun!” The tour includes visits to notable locations like the Historic Downtown Mystic, the Legend of the Massacre at The Harp and Hound, and haunted spots like Friar Tuck’s Tavern and 15 Water St.
Key highlights include discovering the haunted history of Mystic’s old book store, hearing about Revolutionary and colonial ghosts at Captain Daniel Packer Inne, and enjoying three complimentary drinks. The tour’s evening start time of 7:30 pm makes it perfect for a nightcap.
Bottom Line: If you love spooky stories paired with well-crafted cocktails and lively local pubs, this tour offers both in a fun, relaxed atmosphere. It’s especially suited for history fans who want a spirited night out.
2. Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour
Number two is the Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour, which offers a more beer-centric experience for around $75 per person. Lasting about 2.5 hours, this tour takes you through three pubs and breweries, where you’ll sample different local beers—notably three pints of Barley Head brews—and hear tales of Mystic’s haunted past.
This experience is ideal for beer lovers eager to explore local brewing while learning about Mystic’s ghostly legends.
What makes this tour appealing is its relaxed vibe and focus on craft beers. Guides share stories of hauntings and scandals at each stop, including Mystic’s famous massacre and spooky tales from the Water Street area. Reviewers highlight the friendly guide Sierra, calling her “awesome” and noting the engaging storytelling along with the enjoyable beer tasting.
The itinerary includes stops at Mystic’s Historic Downtown, The Harp and Hound, and Water Street, culminating at Captain Daniel Packer Inne with a second beer, then finishing at Friar Tuck’s Tavern with a third pint and folklore tales. The tour’s evening start at 7:30 pm makes it convenient for a late-night session of storytelling and drinking.
Key highlights include tasting three different beers, hearing local legends, and exploring Mystic’s haunted taverns. This tour is best suited for those who prefer craft beers over cocktails and want a laid-back, fun way to learn about Mystic’s dark history.
Bottom Line: If your idea of fun involves local brews and ghost stories without the cocktail focus, this beer tour offers a friendly, relaxed way to enjoy Mystic’s haunted taverns.
How to Choose
When deciding between these tours, consider what kind of drinking experience you prefer. The Spirits of Mystic tour is perfect for those looking for a lively, spooky atmosphere with cocktails and a storytelling edge. If you’re more into craft beers and a casual, beer-focused exploration, the Paranormal Pub Crawl will suit you better.
Think about your budget—at $75 for the beer tour, it’s a bit more affordable—and your interest in spirits versus beers.
Both tours start at the same location and time, making it easy to choose based on your preferred drink style. If you’re a fan of ghost stories, history, and cocktails, go for the Spirits of Mystic: Cocktail Pub Crawl. For a more relaxed, beer-centered experience, the Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour is your best pick.
To sum it up, Mystic offers two excellent options for a memorable night out: one that blends haunted legends with cocktails, and another that celebrates local brews amidst ghostly tales. Both tours boast high ratings and unique experiences that appeal to different tastes. If you’re after a lively, story-rich adventure, the cocktail crawl is hard to beat.
On the other hand, if you prefer sampling local beers and hearing ghost stories, the beer tour provides a laid-back alternative.
To make the most of your trip, consider booking early—especially during peak seasons—as these popular tours tend to fill up. Whichever you choose, a night exploring Mystic’s haunted pubs and breweries promises fun, flavor, and a little spooky intrigue.