True Crime Pub Crawl in New Orleans

If you’re drawn to stories of murder, mystery, and the darker side of city life, the True Crime Pub Crawl in New Orleans offers a unique way to experience the city’s history and its infamous crimes. This tour by Tour Orleans combines storytelling, local taverns, and a dash of history, all wrapped into a lively two-hour adventure through the French Quarter.

It’s a popular choice, with rating 5.0 from 68 reviews and a strong recommendation rate of 97% — that’s no small feat in the world of guided tours.

What we love about this experience is how it manages to blend entertaining storytelling with visits to iconic bars that have historical ties to notorious cases. The knowledgeable guides keep the tales engaging without turning the tour into a dark, gloomy affair.

The other highlight is the opportunity to sip drinks at historic establishments like former brothels and bars linked to famous criminals, giving a genuine feel for the city’s more scandalous past.

However, a potential consideration is the focus on gruesome stories — this isn’t for those who prefer lighter sightseeing or are squeamish about violent tales. The tour leans into the more chilling aspects of New Orleans history, which makes it ideal for true crime enthusiasts or those fascinated by the macabre.

This tour is best suited for adults who enjoy history with a twist of crime, those interested in the local lore and architecture connected to infamous events, and adventurous travelers ready for a spirited night out. If you’re looking for a fun, slightly edgy way to see the French Quarter and learn about its darker history, this tour fits the bill perfectly.

This experience made our article of The 15 Most Popular Drinking Tours In New Orleans.

Key Points

• Authentic storytelling by passionate guides who keep the tales engaging and informative
• Visits to historic bars and landmarks tied to infamous crimes and notable figures
• Two-hour tour that condenses a lot of fascinating history and local lore without feeling rushed
• Plenty of opportunities to sample local drinks at iconic venues
• Suitable for most travelers, with a focus on adults comfortable with mature themes
• Free cancellation allows flexibility if your plans change

A Deep Dive into the True Crime Pub Crawl Experience

Starting Point and First Impressions

The tour kicks off at Tour Orleans’ meeting point on Decatur Street, right in the heart of the French Quarter. From there, you’re greeted with a complimentary hurricane or local beer, a nice touch that sets a casual, welcoming tone. The initial stop at Bon’s New Orleans Street Food is brief but effective, giving you a taste of local flavors and a chance to settle in.

This quick start helps set the scene for what’s ahead — a mix of historical facts, lively storytelling, and a few drinks at some of the city’s most storied bars. The small group size, capped at 20, means personal interaction with guides who are enthusiastic and highly knowledgeable.

Exploring Jackson Square and Surroundings

Walking from the starting point, the tour hits Jackson Square for a quick photo opportunity and a bit of history about the Cabildo and Presbytere — iconic landmarks that speak to New Orleans’ colonial past. You’ll also get a view of the Mississippi River from Washington Artillery Park, which makes for a lovely photo backdrop and a moment to appreciate the city’s geography.

Our guides do a good job weaving in stories about the JFK assassination, connecting the city’s history with national events. It’s fascinating to hear about the alleged involvement of some residents, making the tour more than just local gossip but a genuine, if dark, historical exploration.

Storyville and The Tango Belt

Next, the tour takes you on a walk through Storyville, the historic red-light district, and the Tango Belt, an area notorious for its nightlife and illicit activities. These districts set the stage for some of the crime stories you’ll later hear, tying the physical spaces to the tales of vice and crime that shaped the city’s reputation.

The Gruesome Tales: Bars with Dark Histories

One of the most compelling stops is Jimani Lounge & Restaurant. It’s not only a cozy bar but also the site of what is described as the largest hate crime of the 20th century in New Orleans. The guide recounts the tragedy with sensitivity, emphasizing the importance of remembering victims and understanding the local context.

Next, you visit Three Legged Dog, a lively spot where Zack, from the Zack and Addy murder-suicide story, used to bartend. This personal connection to a notorious case makes the story more visceral — “D.J., the guide, made the entire experience fun and interesting while providing bits of history that we were unaware of,” one reviewer shares.

Another highlight is May Baily’s Place, a historic brothel believed to be the first licensed brothel in New Orleans. Drinking here, amidst the décor and history, transports you back to the city’s more risqué days. The tour’s writers note that this stop offers a glimpse into the city’s seedy past while offering a relaxed atmosphere for a cocktail.

The Dark Tales: Ax Man and Other Local Legends

Throughout the tour, guides narrate stories of the Ax Man, a mysterious serial killer terrorizing the city in the 1960s. It’s the kind of legend that keeps you looking over your shoulder, especially when paired with the atmospheric bars and historic sights.

According to reviews, guides like Wes and Jamie bring enthusiasm and deep knowledge, making the gruesome stories come alive. “Wes was an incredibly good tour guide. Very knowledgeable and so fun!” and “Jamie was very passionate about the stories and history,” are common compliments.

The Drinks and Atmosphere

Part of the charm of this tour is the opportunity to enjoy drinks at each stop. The guide explains the drinks of choice, adding context to the local flavors. At May Baily’s, you might sip a classic cocktail while imagining the lives of the women who once worked there. At Three Legged Dog, a drink enhances the connection to the Zack case, making the stories even more engaging.

Reviewers consistently praise the friendly atmosphere and the personalized service from guides who remember names and share extra tips for local dining and attractions.

Duration, Group Size, and Value

In just two hours, you cover a substantial amount of history, crime lore, and local culture. The small group size ensures everyone can ask questions and enjoy a more intimate experience. The price point of $29.60 per person is quite reasonable considering the length, storytelling quality, and access to historic bars — this offers good value for a memorable night out.

Overall Experience

The reviews speak volumes: “This was one of the best tours of New Orleans,” says one traveler. The guides are consistently described as fun, knowledgeable, and passionate. The mix of history, crime stories, and lively atmosphere makes this tour stand out among other city explorations.

Some reviewers mention a desire for less haunted or cursed material, but most find that the balance of true crime and local history is just right. It’s a tour that appeals to adults who like their history with a side of gore and intrigue, but it’s also accessible enough for casual travelers interested in the city’s lesser-known stories.

The Bottom Line: Who Will Love This Tour?

This True Crime Pub Crawl is a fantastic pick for adventurous travelers, history buffs with a curiosity for the darker aspects of New Orleans, and anyone looking for a fun, social way to explore the city after dark. If you enjoy storytelling that’s both informative and entertaining, and are comfortable with gruesome details, you’ll find plenty to love here.

It’s a value-packed experience that combines history, local flavor, and a lively atmosphere. Plus, the opportunity to visit historic bars and learn about notorious crimes makes it a memorable addition to any trip to the French Quarter.

FAQ

Is the tour suitable for children?
No. This tour is geared toward adults due to its focus on violent crimes and dark themes.

How long is the tour?
Approximately 2 hours, which allows for a good mix of stories and drinks at several stops.

Do I need to book in advance?
Yes. It’s recommended to book about 29 days ahead to secure your spot, especially during peak season.

What is included in the price?
A guided walking tour, visits to historic bars, and a complimentary hurricane or local beer at the start.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the tour.

Are the guides knowledgeable?
Absolutely. The reviews highlight guides like Wes, Jamie, and Richard as engaging, well-informed, and passionate.

Are drinks included at every stop?
You get a drink at the start, and the guides suggest drinks at each bar, but additional drinks are at your own expense.

Is this tour wheelchair accessible?
The information doesn’t specify, but since it involves walking and visiting historic sites, it’s best to inquire directly if accessibility is a concern.

Where does the tour end?
Back at the starting point on Decatur Street, making it easy to continue exploring or return to your accommodations.

In sum, if you’re eager to explore the spookier side of New Orleans through the lens of real stories and local haunts, this tour offers a satisfying mix of history, storytelling, and lively bar stops — a memorable way to spend an evening in the French Quarter.