St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

Setting out on a true crime pub crawl in St. Augustine offers a unique blend of history, storytelling, and local flavor. This tour promises more than just a walk through historic streets—it immerses you in the unsettling tales of unsolved murders, serial killers, and grim episodes that shaped this ancient city.

If you’re intrigued by the darker side of history and enjoy a good story over a drink, this experience might be right up your alley.

What draws many to this tour are two key features: first, the opportunity to sip on local brews and beverages in cozy, atmospheric pubs; second, the engaging storytelling from a knowledgeable guide who brings to life some of St. Augustine’s most notorious crimes.

On the flip side, some might find the focus on crime stories a tad subdued, especially considering that crime in St. Augustine isn’t as rampant as in larger cities, which can make some tales less shocking.

This tour is best suited for those who enjoy a mix of history, mystery, and a relaxed pub atmosphere—perfect for adults with a curious side and an interest in the city’s darker stories.

This experience made our article of St Augustine Florida’s 4 Top Drinking Tours.

Key Points

• Authentic storytelling about local murders and serial killers.
• Visit multiple historic and lively pubs in the heart of St. Augustine.
• Guided by knowledgeable hosts who make the stories come alive.
• Ideal for history buffs and true crime fans seeking a relaxed, social experience.
• Limited to small groups for a more intimate experience.
• Cost-effective at $35 per person for a 2-hour journey through the city’s darker past.

You can check availability for your dates here:

An In-Depth Look at the Blood on the Cobblestones Tour

The St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl is a captivating way to combine a casual drink with dark history. Designed to last around 2 hours, it’s a manageable, evening activity that appeals to those who want a taste of the city’s shadier episodes without a long commitment. The tour is run by Revelry Tours and typically meets at the Ghost City Tours store at 32 Charlotte St.

Starting Point: Meet and Greet at Pizalley’s Chianti Room

You’ll gather here, ready to settle into a cozy atmosphere with a selection of beverages. The guide, often Rob from glowing reviews, sets the tone with a mix of enthusiasm and expertise. This first stop is crucial because it sets the pace for the stories to come. You’ll learn about William Darrell Lindsey, a serial killer active between 1983 and 1996, who targeted addicts and sex workers. Our guide’s knack for storytelling makes these grim tales stick—yet in a captivating way, not a sensationalized one.

The First Stop: Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila

Next, you’ll move to a lively spot with good drinks and an even more intriguing story—Father Rene Robert. Known for helping ex-convicts, his murder remains unsolved, adding a layer of mystery to this stop. The guide’s detailed retelling helps you picture the scene, making the story more visceral. The casual pub environment allows you to relax and soak in the history without feeling like you’re on a typical tour.

The Oldest Streets and Forgotten Tonic

Moving along to Forgotten Tonic, you’ll hear about a murder that took place on March 2, 1800, on Aviles Street, the longest continuously inhabited street in the U.S. This story’s age and the enduring mystery add a sense of historical gravity. It’s a reminder that some crimes from centuries ago still captivate and puzzle investigators today.

More Great Tours Nearby

Heart of Downtown: Saint George Street and Cathedral Place

Here, the tour takes you into the bustling core of St. Augustine. You’ll get the chance to purchase drinks and hear about the unsolved murder case of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney. The stories extend into more recent history, including the murder of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, a model and TV personality whose death remains an open case. The guides excel at weaving these stories into the vibrant surroundings, making history feel alive.

Ending at Prohibition Kitchen

Your final stop is at a vintage gastropub, where you can enjoy a drink and reflect on the tales. The guide often shares some last stories, leaving you with plenty to ponder as you head back into the night.

The Experience and Atmosphere

What makes this tour stand out is its combination of storytelling and atmosphere. The pubs visited—like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina—are carefully chosen for their charm and authenticity. Each offers a cozy, often historic vibe that enhances the storytelling experience. The group size is limited to 9 participants, ensuring personal attention and lively conversation.

Participants generally appreciate the knowledge and enthusiasm of the guides. As one reviewer states, “Rob is the man! – amazing and knowledgeable tour guide,” which confirms that the storytelling quality is high. The casual environment encourages conversation and camaraderie, which can be especially enjoyable if you’re traveling with friends or meeting new ones.

What to Expect

The journey covers about 0.9 miles on foot, so comfortable shoes are recommended. The tour runs rain or shine, so come prepared for the weather. You’ll be encouraged to bring ID or passport, especially since alcohol is involved, and video recording isn’t allowed—probably out of respect for the stories and privacy.

Value for Money

At $35 per person, this tour is quite affordable given the duration and the intimate setting. You’re paying primarily for the storytelling, the guide’s expertise, and the experience of walking through historic streets at night. While drinks aren’t included, the stops are designed to complement the stories, not overshadow them.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This experience is perfect for adults who enjoy history, true crime, and casual social outings. It’s well-suited for those looking for a relaxed evening activity rather than a serious, in-depth crime investigation. If you’re interested in authentic local stories and want a fun way to explore St. Augustine’s historic streets, this tour offers a memorable blend of entertainment and education.

It’s probably not ideal for young travelers under 21 or those seeking a more structured museum-style experience. But if you love stories that combine history, mystery, and a little bit of spooky fun over a drink or two, this guided pub crawl could be a highlight of your trip.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

For the price, the St. Augustine True Crime Guided Pub Crawl offers a distinctive way to see the city’s historic core while indulging your curiosity about its darker episodes. The intimate setting, knowledgeable guides, and engaging stories make it a worthwhile choice for those who enjoy storytelling, history, and a relaxed social vibe.

While it might not satisfy thrill-seekers looking for intense crime stories, it’s perfect for travelers who appreciate a good tale combined with the ambiance of local pubs. The reviews reflect that many guests leave feeling both entertained and slightly haunted by the stories they’ve heard—an authentic taste of St. Augustine’s long, sometimes gruesome, history.

If you’re after an evening that’s both fun and a little eerie, this tour delivers in spades—an unusual way to explore a city famed for its ghosts and legends.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for all adults?
Yes, but it’s designed for those 21 and older, as alcohol is involved and the stories are intended for mature audiences.

How long does the tour last?
It lasts approximately 2 hours, making it a manageable evening activity.

Are drinks included?
No, drinks are not included in the price, but you are free to purchase beverages at each stop.

Where does the tour meet?
You meet your guide at Pizalley’s Chianti Room, located at 32 Charlotte St.

What should I bring?
Bring a valid ID or passport and be prepared for weather—umbrella or rain jacket if needed.

Is the tour walkable?
Yes, the route covers about 0.9 miles, primarily walking through the historic streets of St. Augustine.

Can I record the stories?
Video recording isn’t allowed, likely to respect privacy and the storytelling atmosphere.

What if it rains?
The tour takes place rain or shine, so dress appropriately and be prepared for the weather.

In the end, this tour offers a fascinating peek into St. Augustine’s more sinister tales, all wrapped up in a friendly, social setting. It’s a great way to add some intrigue and local flavor to your visit, especially if you enjoy stories that are as much about the atmosphere as the history.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby